COVID-19 is more than a pandemic; it is a revealer of many inequalities and biases inherent in our daily lives. Our Director, Dr Doyin Atewologun, is working with colleagues in the NHS to help leaders and managers understand the psychological impact of working on the frontline for our NHS, particularly the implications for diversity. We welcome the investigation into the COVID-19 deaths of BAME doctors that is happening alongside broader investigations on the impact of COVID-19 on the BAME community. We continue to support efforts to make sure that the impact of COVID-19 does not disrupt diversity and inclusion efforts in business, and we continue to ask questions which highlight the diversity of identities and experiences within the BAME community to progress D&I initiatives. In this article, we turn our attention to intersectionality.
What is intersectionality?
Evidence already shows that black women are five times more likely to die in pregnancy, birth and postpartum than white women. The experiences of BAME women are different to those of white women, and also different to the experiences of BAME men – but in practice who in particular is the focus when we talk about “women” and “BAME” groups?
Doyin’s article “Intersectionality Theory and Practice” was ranked as the 5th most popular in the Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Business and Management in 2019 and was listed among the top 10 websites for inclusion by Aishnine Benjamin in her article published 6th February 2020.
In short, intersectionality recognises that:
Despite this, research shows that when people think about targets of gender discrimination, they imagine white women, and when they think of targets of racism, they think of black men. Consequently, we find that women’s programmes are often designed to address white women’s needs and BAME programmes are implicitly designed to address challenges facing BAME men. Additionally, within the category of BAME, there are distinctions between the experiences of different minority groups. We need intersectional skills, mindset and knowhow to account for the ways in which the experiences of black women may differ from the experiences of black men, Asian women, those who were not born in the country, and other minority groups who contribute to our organisation. It’s not about having all the answers to the specific differences between the groups; rather, it’s about having the insights and motivation to be aware of the complexity, ask the questions, and build up inclusive and responsive dexterity in all our talent management professionals and their interventions.
Why is it important and urgent to apply intersectionality to targeted talent programmes?
Considering the implications of intersectionality on the attraction, retention and progression of all under-represented talent is an important next step in the evolution of D&I and talent management practices in leading organisations. If intersectionality is not included in D&I practices, leadership and talent progression programmes, then the leadership strategy is incomplete, not inclusive and likely to be only partially effective (and potentially a waste of resources).
Overlooking intersectionality in women’s leadership programmes and executive coaching can have a significant impact on the pay gaps, performance appraisals, sense of well-being and conflict faced by some women, especially those who identify as Black, Asian or Minority Ethnic (BAME). For example, women’s leadership programmes often deal with the “double bind”: the need to balance the tension of being seen as warm and likeable with the need to be seen as competent and assertive. However, as Doyin’s article explains, this has different implications for black, Asian and white women. Consequently, a generalised approach to building awareness of the double bind will be inappropriate and could harm, misguide and exclude women of colour and will likely exclude other sub-identity groups in your workplace (such as gay Asian men or older women). It is critical that professional facilitators and coaches have a deep and inclusive understanding of the barriers and challenges faced by the communities they are working with, rather than an imagined universal experience of inequality.
Why do organisations struggle with taking an intersectional approach?
There is often hesitation to integrate intersectionality into business and leadership practices. It is often perceived as too complex for traditional leadership and talent management initiatives. However, the discomfort associated with speaking about some identities over others may explain the hesitation. Our experience has shown that organisational leaders find it harder to talk about race and ethnicity than they do about gender. For example, our research for the Parker Review of Ethnicity in FTSE 350 companies shows that organisations still struggle to articulate their policies and strategies for increasing minority ethnic members on their boards.
Sir John Parker speaks to this challenge and states in the report: “I know that, even more than with gender, for every Chairman or CEO reading this report, this feels like dangerous territory. But we need to understand that in today’s world, failure to act can be just as damaging to our companies’ reputations, not to mention weakening shareholder and stakeholder confidence. This is not just a matter of social justice. Many of those who invest in us and trust us as our customers are now monitoring our performance on leadership diversity, because they see it as a sign of whether we are truly ready to face up to the challenge of the modern world.”
In summary, intersectionality is a necessary lens through which to view D&I. Without it, strategies risk overlooking and even sabotaging members of the very group that they set out to serve. One of the major barriers to adopting an intersectional approach is the discomfort of talking about some identities, such as race and ethnicity. Race fluency can help organisations to overcome this challenge. It is time for organisations to bridge the gaps between gender and leadership and race and leadership by putting intersectionality into practice in leadership and talent progression solutions.
Our team of inclusion experts is ready to support you to further explore ways you can integrate intersectionality and race fluency into all your D&I and talent management initiatives. As part of our Open Mind Series, we offer Thought Leadership insights and evidence-based webinars on the key business challenges you are facing today in inclusion and diversity. See our recent article Bias: Actions and Reactions in an Uncertain World. Let us help you keep your people development and D&I strategies on track with our digital and live virtual learning solutions.
Delta provides evidence-based, bespoke solutions for diversity and inclusion business needs. We offer research and insights, inclusive culture ‘building blocks’ through virtual and in-person workshops for workplace groups across the business, ecosystem programmes to embed change for meeting strategic D&I objectives, and culturally intelligent executive coaching.